I decided to purchase Lodge scent-unsmelled because 1) I have loved all of my other Hotel Lobby purchases, so #trust and 2) I read all the fragrance notes and figured, 'that list sounds good to me!' In summary, I am happy but not thrilled with Lodge (I was, for exampled, THRILLED with Holiday). The overall quality is still excellent, the brown color is luxurious, and the scent is nice... but it's less sexy-wood-cabin-earthy-toasty-hot-lumberjack as I was hoping, and more... dapper old man who I wouldn't mind sitting next to in the theatre for a couple hours. I'm still going to burn the whole thing, but I'd sooner purchase another New York or Holiday for my fall/winter vibes before Lodge again!